Tax exemption for nonprofit hospitals, valued at over $10 billion in 2018, has been a subject of debate among various stakeholders. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, the American Hospital Association, and experts like Elisabeth Rosenthal have all contributed to this ongoing discussion. The recent nomination of vice-presidential candidate J.D. Vance has only intensified the focus on this issue.
The debate revolves around whether nonprofit hospitals provide sufficient community benefits to justify their tax-exempt status. The Community Health Needs Assessment (CHNA) that Congress mandates for these hospitals was originally seen as a potential solution to this debate. Still, the tool falls short when it comes to requiring the reconciliation of their charitable resources against their community benefits.
Nonprofit hospitals have the opportunity to voluntarily assess and report their charitable resources used in providing community benefits, similar to how for-profit businesses manage their profits. This evaluation could help non-profit hospital boards gauge how effectively they are fulfilling their charitable missions.
A fundamental question arises: Can a charity truly be non-charitable? While a nonprofit charity doesn’t generate profits for shareholders, executives can still maximize their income or misuse charitable resources. Only a fraction of top executives from nonprofit hospitals have their pay linked to community health improvement activities.
Consider two hospitals, one for-profit and the other a nonprofit charity, both providing free or low-fee care in the same city. The for-profit hospital’s net worth benefits shareholders, whereas the charity’s net worth, held in endowments, arises from contributions over time. If the nonprofit hospital obtains new contributions, the profit-making hospital does not. How these funds are used for charitable endeavors significantly impacts the hospital’s charitable standing.
To enhance these assessments, matching charitable resources to their application could provide visibility into the size and impact of a nonprofit hospital’s charitable initiatives. Quantifying the charitable utilization of available resources remains complex due to the differing activities undertaken by nonprofit and for-profit hospitals. Proper accounting practices can aid in gauging a hospital’s charitable performance accurately.
Ultimately, improved assessments would benefit not only policymakers and regulatory bodies but also individual contributors, consumers, and taxpayers. Ensuring that nonprofit tax-exempt hospitals serve the public’s interest can solidify their essential role as charitable organizations. By focusing on transparency and accountability, these hospitals can uphold their commitment to the communities they serve.
Leave feedback about this