The Failure of Index-Linked Investments: A Close Look After Covid
Index-linked bonds are heralded as a shield against inflation, a pillar of stability in uncertain times. Yet, the post-Covid era has tested this belief, unveiling cracks in the seemingly bulletproof armor of these investments. As I delved into the performance of index-linked bond funds post-pandemic, questions brewed in my mind. Do they truly deliver on their promise of safeguarding us from inflation’s wrath? Moreover, can individual index-linked gilts stand tall as a reliable inflation hedge?
- The Short vs. Long Duration Dilemma:
- Short-duration index-linked funds were our go-to choice at House Money pre-Covid upheaval. These funds typically exhibit returns closely aligned with inflation adjustments while sidestepping the tumultuous price swings triggered by soaring interest rates.
- In contrast, long-duration index-linked funds floundered in the wake of rising interest rates in 2022. Their vulnerability was laid bare as prices plummeted, nullifying the inflation protection they promised. A cautionary tale, indeed.
- The Weakest Link(ers) Unveiled:
- Picture yourself in October 2021, gazing out to sea, bracing for the onslaught of inflation, armed with short-duration linker bond fund units.
- Alas, the reality was far from ideal. The performance of these short-duration funds against inflation showcased a disappointing spectacle:
- UK CPI inflation: 5.9%
- Short-duration linker fund return: 0.6%
- The glaring divergence between these figures unveiled a stark truth – the funds fell woefully short in keeping pace with the inflation surge.
- Individual Index-Linked Gilts: A Ray of Hope?
- Individual index-linked gilts, with their built-in inflation protection, surface as a beacon of hope in turbulent times. A simple strategy of buy-and-hold can shield investors from the losses that bond funds are susceptible to.
- However, the recent price spiral raised doubts about their efficacy as an inflation hedge. Did they truly deliver during the tumultuous period?
- Delving Deeper: The Performance Analysis:
- A meticulous simulation of a portfolio of individual index-linked gilts was undertaken, pitting them against CPI inflation and the short-duration linker fund.
- The results were telling:
- Inflation: 5.9%
- Individual linkers return: 4.1%
- Linker fund return: 0.6%
- A discernible gap persisted, underscoring the challenges investors faced in navigating the inflationary storm.
- Unraveling the Conundrum:
- The conundrum lay in the negative yields that burdened individual index-linked gilts back in 2021. This negative yield impeded their ability to keep pace with inflation, perpetuating a cycle of underperformance.
- However, with current index-linked gilts priced on positive yields, the outlook appears brighter. Investors can now embark on a path where inflation no longer poses an insurmountable obstacle.
In conclusion, the turbulent landscape post-Covid has shed light on the shortcomings of index-linked investments. As I bid adieu to index-linked bond funds, I tread a new path, one guided by the promise of individual index-linked gilts. An era of stability beckons, beckoning investors to seek refuge where inflation’s sting is blunted.
Leave feedback about this