The allure of tariffs has always captivated Donald Trump. In a recent speech in Chicago, he declared his love for the word "tariffs," claiming it to be his favorite word. Trump strongly believes that tariffs are the linchpin of economic and social resurgence, vowing to bring back American companies, lower taxes, and safeguard domestic production with robust tariffs. This fervor for tariffs puzzles traditional economists, who foresee potential inflation and trade conflict. Meanwhile, Democrats, like Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, criticize tariffs as misguided.
However, tariffs hold a deeper significance beyond mere economic policy. They serve as potent political and rhetorical tools, historically ingrained in the fabric of the Republican Party. For Trump, a return to the Republican tradition of tariffs from the 19th century serves as a unifying principle, resonating politically and culturally with his supporters.
-
Historic Role of Tariffs:
- During the eras of William McKinley and his Republican counterparts, tariffs were revered as economic remedies protecting American industries and worker wages. McKinley famously christened himself as a "tariff man," advocating for tariffs as a central policy.
-
Political Function:
- Tariffs were instrumental in consolidating divergent state organizations into a formidable national coalition among Republicans. The protective tariff not only favored industrial hubs but also garnered the support of additional constituencies like Midwest wool producers and organized labor unions.
-
Tariffs as Social Policy:
- Republican leaders during the Gilded Age viewed tariffs as the cornerstone of social stability, promoting higher wages and employment opportunities to nurture family life and uphold traditional values. The tariff symbolized progress, prosperity, and moral rectitude within the party’s ideology.
- Evolution of Republican Stance:
- In the aftermath of World War II, Republican sentiments toward tariffs shifted intermittently, culminating in a wholehearted embrace of free trade during the Reagan era. The current resurgence of tariff-centric policies under Trump echoes a strategic cultural alignment rather than a mere economic deviation.
Trump’s fixation on tariffs transcends conventional economic rationale, embodying a deeply entrenched vision of national pride and protection. As the political landscape unfolds, it becomes imperative for his opponents, like Kamala Harris, to grasp the political underpinnings of tariffs as a strategy rather than a mere economic tool. In the grand tapestry of history, tariffs weave a tale of political expediency and cultural identity that continues to shape the political landscape today.
