In today’s fast-paced world, the sentiments of consumers and businesses play a crucial role in influencing a wide array of aspects, ranging from stock market trends to electoral outcomes and even everyday purchasing behaviors. But what exactly drives these sentiments? To delve into this question, we delved into measures of confidence and the underlying factors that have shaped consumer and business sentiments dating back to the 1980s. However, what we uncovered is both intriguing and concerning – the factors that once reliably indicated the direction of sentiments are no longer as dependable as they used to be.
Exploring indices such as the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index (UMCSENT), the Consumer Confidence Index (CCI), and the Business Confidence Index (BCI), we analyzed macroeconomic variables such as unemployment rates, interest rates, GDP growth, inflation rates, stock market performances, and various others to discern their impact on sentiments.
Our analysis involved regressing each sentiment measure against these macro variables, segmented by decade. The findings were illuminating, with historical accuracy making way for increasing unpredictability and inconsistency in recent times. Figures 1, 2, and 3 depict the results of our model focusing on UMCSENT, CCI, and BCI, respectively. Symbols such as “+” and “x” were used to denote the significance and direction of the coefficients, indicating a shift from established historical patterns.
One noteworthy discovery from our analysis is the diminishing predictability of our models over time. For instance, factors such as GDP growth, unemployment rates, and inflation, which once had a clear impact on consumer sentiments, have seen their influence wane in the post-COVID era. In the 1980s, changes in inflation rates and unemployment levels could be correlated with substantial shifts in consumer confidence. However, in more recent times, only inflation and stock market returns seem to have any significant power in predicting consumer sentiment.
Quantifying this phenomenon, we observed that a mere one percentage point rise in inflation during the 1980s led to a 3.4-point decline in the Michigan index. Fast forward to the present day, the corresponding impact had significantly weakened to a 1.1-point drop. Similarly, the predictive capability of our models, as evidenced by the Adjusted-R^2, has progressively declined from an impressive 0.88 in the 1980s to a mere 0.72 today.
While the causes of this diminishing predictability are manifold, one salient factor that has been postulated in existing literature is partisanship. The influence of political affiliations on attitudes towards the economy and sentiments, especially during electoral periods, could be a crucial factor that we did not account for in our study.
In conclusion, with traditional metrics like unemployment rates and GDP growth failing to provide insights into consumer sentiments, it is evident that a more nuanced and in-depth investigation of the underlying causes of this paradigm shift is imperative. As we navigate these evolving trends, a deeper understanding of the factors driving consumer and business sentiments is essential for informed decision-making and policy formulation in an increasingly volatile economic landscape.
Leave feedback about this