Completely rewrite the following article in a fresh and original style. Ensure the new content conveys the same sentiment and message as the original. The rewritten article should:
- Start with a compelling introduction that hooks the reader (do not label this section).
- Maintain any lists and points as they are, using numbering and bullet points where necessary. Rewrite the explanations and discussions around these points to make them fresh and original. Ensure the lists are formatted correctly with proper numbering or bullet points.
-
Organize the content into clear, logical sections. Subheadings are not mandatory. Each section should have a subheading only if it enhances readability and comprehension.
-
End with a strong conclusion that summarizes the key points and provides a closing thought or call to action (do not label this section).
-
Ensure it is formatted properly with adequate line spacing
Make sure the article flows coherently, is engaging, and keeps the reader interested until the end. Reorganize and structure the content efficiently to enhance readability and comprehension. Use varied sentence structures and vocabulary to avoid monotony. Avoid directly copying any sentences or phrases from the original content. Here is the original content:
Sales taxA sales tax is levied on retail sales of goods and services and, ideally, should apply to all final consumption with few exemptions. Many governments exempt goods like groceries; base broadening, such as including groceries, could keep rates lower. A sales tax should exempt business-to-business transactions which, when taxed, cause tax pyramiding.
holidays, designated periods when select goods or services are exempted from state (and sometimes local) sales taxes, continue to be politically popular among the states: 19 have held or will be holding sales taxA tax is a mandatory payment or charge collected by local, state, and national governments from individuals or businesses to cover the costs of general government services, goods, and activities.
holidays in 2024, one more than last year.
They also take different forms in different places. In recent years, Florida has exempted outdoor recreational equipment from its state sales tax during the summer, while Iowa and Oklahoma have exempted clothing during their holidays. Sales tax holidays are politically popular with elected officials because they offer direct discounts, whether real or perceived, to consumers in a highly visible way. Consumers often believe they’re getting a good deal. Thus, they remain popular despite their economic inefficiencies, unintended consequences, and frequent inability to achieve their stated goals.
Proponents of sales tax holidays claim they create economic growth by increasing retail activity within their timeframes. However, studies show that much of the increased shopping during holidays is shopping that consumers would have done at other times but moved to the holiday timeframe to take advantage of discounts. While some consumers make incidental “impulse” purchases during these holidays, those additional purchases are not enough to justify the revenue costs associated with these holidays, even if such impulse purchases are desirable. Since sales tax holidays shift the timing of demand but do little to increase its magnitude, sales tax holidays reduce state and local tax collections for little or no economic benefit.
Additionally, states often schedule sales tax holidays to exempt specified goods and services during times when demand for these goods and services is highest, such as back-to-school products in August and hurricane preparedness supplies before storm seasons. As a result, most of these revenue losses are associated with retail transactions that would have occurred without the added incentive. The prevalence of sales tax holidays is indicative of deeper structural weaknesses in state tax codes: the existence of a sales tax holidayA sales tax holiday is a period of time when selected goods are exempted from state (and sometimes local) sales taxes. Such holidays have become an annual event in many states, with exemptions for such targeted products as back-to-school supplies, clothing, computers, hurricane preparedness supplies, and more.
is a tacit admission that the sales tax is overly burdensome throughout the rest of the year.
While these revenue losses may not be particularly large, they still have to be offset by revenue generated elsewhere, which is a net negative for states’ overall economic health since other revenue sources are often more economically damaging than sales taxes. And states that can consistently cover these holidays out of surplus revenues could better utilize their excess funds on more economically efficient tax reforms, particularly rate reductions.
Proponents of sales tax holidays sometimes suggest that they encourage out-of-state consumers to travel for discounts, increasing in-state sales. Since so many states now have tax holidays, and because the holidays often apply to lower-cost items that wouldn’t justify a large detour, their effect on consumer behavior is dubious. Furthermore, while compliance is undeniably low, a consumer who makes a sales-tax-free, out-of-state purchase intended to be consumed in their own state is legally obligated to pay use tax on that purchase.
Tax holidays also incentivize consumers to put off shopping for selected items. A lower-income family that waits to buy school supplies until a back-to-school sales tax holiday on the weekend before school starts—a point when many families have already finished their shopping—might have been better off if they had shopped earlier, when products are most likely to be well stocked. This is just one aspect of sales tax holidays that can inadvertently harm lower-income consumers. Because sales tax holidays induce high demand for an often narrow, predetermined set of goods during a limited timeframe, retailers often increase prices to avoid running out of stock. Though this aspect of sales tax holidays is difficult to study, some research has suggested companies can absorb up to 20 percent of the benefit of sales tax holidays through price increases, hurting consumers with the lowest incomes. These shoppers are also the most likely to face difficulties in being able to prepare for sales tax holidays by increasing household savings or requesting time off work. If governments truly want to help low-income consumers, targeted assistance policies are better options. Better yet, policymakers could permanently ease tax burdens by trimming rates year-round—but permanent solutions tend to be deprioritized when politically easier temporary gimmicks like sales tax holidays persist.
In addition to their inefficiencies as a vehicle for tax relief, sales tax holidays often have economically distortive structural flaws. For example, by imposing a cap on the price of goods that qualify for the sales tax holiday, consumers may be influenced to purchase a less expensive and lower quality product when they otherwise would have purchased a higher quality product that exceeds the specified price threshold. Low price caps can also disadvantage goods from small businesses whose prices may be higher.
The compliance costs associated with sales tax holidays are further damaging to small businesses. Additional short-term staffing is often necessary to handle the induced spikes in demand, and that can be harder to schedule for businesses with fewer employees. Moreover, small businesses may find it more difficult to absorb the spending slowdowns in the weeks immediately before and after sales tax holidays, as consistent revenue is more important when margins are thin. Even if overall revenue remains only slightly changed, the timing distortions can be painful. Additionally, the work required to comply with sales tax holiday provisions (e.g., determining which products qualify for exemption and changing cash register settings in accordance) can be especially difficult for small businesses, which are often unable to sustain entire teams dedicated to legal compliance.
Sales tax holiday structures vary widely from state to state, exacerbating these compliance difficulties. Beyond the differences in product lists and price caps, different states treat shipping, handling, layaway sales, and “rain check” sales differently. The difficult task of compliance must often be done on short notice, because details sometimes aren’t agreed to until just weeks before holidays are scheduled to take place. Take Massachusetts’ sales tax holiday for this year: it must occur at some point during August. Massachusetts legislators chose to give the Massachusetts Department of Revenue multiple weeks to determine when the 2024 state sales tax holiday will be held. Statutorily, it may not need to be for weeks. Such administrative delays encourage administrative slowdowns which could be harmful, or at least, not as helpful, if they choose dates during which demand is low for the qualifying set of goods and services covered under the state’s sales tax holiday.
For small online retailers selling into Massachusetts, among others, this is a nightmare. There are legal consequences for over-collecting sales tax from consumers, so they need to adjust to sales tax holidays that may be called at the last moment, on an evolving range of products, and often with definitions that require careful product-by-product eligibility judgments.
Some businesses thrive on sales tax holidays while others struggle to comply with them. Some consumers benefit from them while others might be inadvertently hurt by them. Sales tax holidays pick winners and losers—and their costs aren’t offset by any meaningful economic benefit.
Nevada recently implemented a sales tax holiday for National Guard members. SB 50 requires Nevada National Guard members to pay the sales tax on eligible items, then submit a request for a refund of the tax, a copy of the letter of exemption issued to the person, and the receipt issued to the person by the retailer indicating that the person paid the tax. Only then will Nevada National Guard members receive a refund and benefit from the sales tax holiday. Is this an efficient or desirable system?
From a political standpoint, sales tax holidays are harmful because they create space for politicians and regulators to pick political favorites in the process of selecting eligible products. They also pave the way for lobbyists to solicit policymakers in hopes of securing a sales tax holiday exemption for their products. Because small retail businesses often lack resources for lobbying, and because there is no way for legislators to perfectly know what consumers want. The lists of goods included in tax holidays can become an unholy matrimony of centralized economic planning and corporate lobbying. Any decision about which goods are and aren’t exempt will discriminate against some consumers.
Overall, sales tax holidays are an inefficient vehicle for providing tax relief or generating additional economic activity. They often end up hurting the taxpayers they intend to help. They inject unnecessary instability into government and business revenue streams; create administrative and compliance costs for businesses, governments, and consumers; and do not promote long-term economic growth. Several states realized these downfalls and accordingly abandoned their sales tax holidays in recent years. However, their electoral utility remains an incentive for policymakers, and with 19 states offering sales tax holidays in 2024—an increase over recent years—it doesn’t look like they’re going away any time soon.
For a more detailed analysis of the arguments for and against sales tax holidays, see our 2022 full-length report.
Stay informed on the tax policies impacting you.Subscribe to get insights from our trusted experts delivered straight to your inbox.
Subscribe
Alabama Sales Tax Holidays
February 23–25
Portable generators and power cords ($1,000)
Severe weather preparedness supplies ($60)
July 19–21, 2024 – Back to School
Computers, computer software, and school computer supplies ($750)
Clothing ($100 or less)
School supplies, school art supplies, school instructional material ($50)
Books ($30)
Alaska Sales Tax Holiday*
October 1, 2023 – March 31
All retail sales (no cap)
* = Alaska does not assess a state sales tax rate. However, the state constitution allows municipalities, defined as cities and boroughs, to assess a local option sales tax. Only one municipality, the Skagway Borough, passed a resolution enacting a local sales tax holiday from October 1, 2024 – March 31, 2024.
Arkansas Sales Tax Holiday
August 3–4
Clothing ($100)
Clothing accessories/cosmetics ($50)
Electronic devices (no cap)
School supplies, school art supplies, school instructional material (no cap)
Florida Sales Tax Holidays
July 1, 2022 – June 30
Impact-resistant doors, windows, and garage doors (no cap)
July 1, 2023 – June 30
Gas ranges/cooktops: (no cap)
ENERGY STAR appliances:
Washers/Dryers/Water Heaters ($1,500)
Refrigerators ($4,500)
July 1-31
Wide range of goods/services related to summer family activities, with some admissions prices exempt from July 1-end of year (See this infographic for specifics:
January 1-14, July 29 – August 11
Computers ($1,500)
Clothing ($100)
School supplies ($50)
Learning aids and jigsaw puzzles ($30)
June 1-14, August 24 – September 6
Disaster preparedness supplies (See this infographic for specifics:
September 1-7
Tools/tool-related equipment
Iowa Sales Tax Holiday
September 6-8
Firearms, ammunition, and hunting supplies (no cap, though it only applies to consumer purchases, not business or commercial purchases).
Maryland Sales Tax Holidays
February 17-19
Solar water heaters and ENERGY STAR products (no cap)
August 11–17
Clothing and footwear ($100)
Some backpacks (first $40 exempt from sales tax)
Massachusetts Sales Tax Holiday
August 10-11
Virtually all retail items for personal consumption ($2,500 or less). Last year, there were many exceptions, though, so check the MA DOR website for current year exemptions and dates (both TBD).
The list of exemptions include:
Meals
Motor vehicles
Motorboats
Telecommunications services
Gas
Steam
Electricity
Tobacco products
Marijuana or marijuana products
Alcoholic beverages
Any single item whose price is more than $2,500; for items above $2,500 purchased during the sales tax holiday, the first $2,500 is exempt from sales tax
Layaway sales
Rentals for periods of longer than 30 days
July 12-14
Clothing and footwear ($100)
School supplies ($100)
August 3 – September 1
Firearms, ammunition, hunting supplies, and firearm safety equipment (excluding safes) (no cap)
Missouri Sales Tax Holidays
April 19-25
ENERGY STAR products ($1,500)
August 2-4
Clothing ($100)
PCs and related hardware supplies ($1,500)
Computer software ($350)
Graphing calculators ($150)
School supplies ($50)
Nevada Sales Tax Holiday*
October 25-27
All purchases (no cap) by Nevada National Guard members. Must apply through Commanding Officers minimum thirty days in advance.
(*) = Nevada amended its state sales tax holiday provisions for National Guard through SB 50 during its 2023 legislative session. Under prior law, Nevada businesses selling qualified goods and services during the sales tax holiday simply exempted the qualifying products from the state sales tax. As of the 2024 state sales tax holiday, consumers must first pay the sales tax, then submit three separate documents to receive a refund of the sales tax. This introduces inefficiencies and creates the distinct possibility of National Guard members not going through the trouble of filing to receive the small benefit the state sales tax holiday provides.
New Mexico Sales Tax Holidays
August 2-4
Bookbags, maps, and globes ($100)
Clothing, footwear, and accessories ($100)
Computers (including tablets and e-readers with computing functions) ($1,000)
Computer-related supplies ($500)
Calculators ($200)
School supplies ($30)
November 30
Many different categories of retail items at qualifying small businesses ($500) (see infographic below for specifics)
Ohio Sales Tax Holiday
July 30 – August 8
Most tangible retail purchases (excludes motor watercraft and alcohol/tobacco/vape/marijuana) ($500)
Oklahoma Sales Tax Holiday
August 2-4
Clothing and footwear (no cap)
Computers, printers/printer supplies, and software (excluding business purchases and handheld phones) (no cap)
School supplies (no cap)
Select bed/bath products and related products (no cap)
July 26-28
Clothing ($100)
Computers, laptops, and tablets ($1,500)
School supplies/school art supplies ($100)
Food and food ingredients (excluding alcohol) (no cap)
Texas Sales Tax Holidays
April 27-29
Hurricane shutters and emergency ladders ($300)
Portable generators ($3,000)
Specific emergency preparation supplies ($75) (see the following webpage for specifics:
May 25-27
WaterSense products for personal/business use (no cap)
Generally water-conserving products (personal use only) (no cap)
ENERGY STAR air conditioners ($6,000), refrigerators ($2,000), and other specified products (no cap) (see the sources below for specifics)
August 9-11
Clothing and footwear ($100)
School supplies and backpacks ($100)
Virginia Sales Tax Holiday
August 2-4
Clothing and footwear ($100)
ENERGY STAR and WaterSense products ($2,500)
Gas-powered chain saws ($350)
Portable generators ($1,000)
School supplies ($20)
Emergency and hurricane preparedness items ($60)
August 2-5
Clothing and footwear ($125)
Laptops and tablets ($500)
School instructional materials ($20)
School supplies ($50)
Sports equipment ($150)
Stay informed on the tax policies impacting you.Subscribe to get insights from our trusted experts delivered straight to your inbox.
Subscribe
Share
Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook
Email
Leave feedback about this